Allison, when I was diagnosed, I was given the goals of 110 or less fasting blood sugar and 140 or less 2 hrs after the first bite of food. This is lower than the ADA recommended #s, but the doctor said the closer to the non-diabetic #s I can stay, the better off i'll be.
Prolonged high blood sugars can cause all kinds of complications, so i'd avoid being over 140 as much as possible...and if you continuously go into the 180-200 range after meals, i'd suggest trying some other foods.
Testing 2 hrs after your first bite will help you learn how different foods affect your blood sugar and help you make smarter food choices. When first diagnosed, I kept a food journal, writing down everything I ate and the corresponding blood sugars. Before too long, I had several blood-sugar friendly meals, and meals became much less stressful.
There's a great book for new T2s, "The First Year, Type 2 Diabetse," by Gretchen Becker. It's a great resource.
Also, post often, you can learn a lot from this place...I know I have.
T2, diagnosed 8/31/06.
Metformin 500 mg twice daily
HCTZ 12.5 mg every other day for BP
Enalapril 20 mg 1 daily (ace-inhibitor)
Lower carb dieter (approx. 75 total carbs/day, more on weekends), taking chromium, multivitamin and fish oil tablets
Initial A1C 8/06: 9.6
11/06: 6.2.
03/07: 5.3
06/07: 5.4
10/07: 5.3
05/08: 6.2 (after dealing with shingles & bronchiti)
2/09: 5.5
5/10: 5.8 (home test)