Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

jojeti

Why not "normal" BGL's?

49 posts in this topic

AnCapMan in his previous hospital post said while in the hospital they took him off meds because they felt his bgl's were too low (80's) for a diabetic. This brings up a question I have. A few times in these forums I have seen where doctors say diabetics bgl should be higher than a "normal" person, my question is why? Why do some doctors say that? Any reasoning behind it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AnCapMan in his previous hospital post said while in the hospital they took him off meds because they felt his bgl's were too low (80's) for a diabetic. This brings up a question I have. A few times in these forums I have seen where doctors say diabetics bgl should be higher than a "normal" person, my question is why? Why do some doctors say that? Any reasoning behind it?

 

If you inject insulin you keep your BG a little high to avoid Hypo's.:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you are on insulin there is an increased risk of hypos associated with lower BG and studies that show increased mortality (thought to be associated with the increase in hypos). I can see no reason why people not on insulin or sulfonylureas should set whatever target they want. That said, below 6.5 there is little change in absolute risk as opposed to percentage change in risk - arguably the benefits aren't worth the sacrifice for some people.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So...I am on Lantus, does that mean I should not go for 80's-90's? I think if someone wants tight control, regardless if they are on insulin, they should be able to do it. It just means more closely watching numbers so you don't get too low.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was waking in the early 80's and even 70's so I decreased my Levemir (since I lowered my carbs). I was not feeling low, but worried what might be happening in my sleep. Only my wakeup number changed.

 

I also was worried my Endo would say my A1c was too low, and would take me off the Lev altogether ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I also was worried my Endo would say my A1c was too low, and would take me off the Lev altogether ...

 

What a Catch-22. Your BG level is within a wonderful range with the Levemir and it's possible that the doctor will eliminate the Levemir, then your BG will rise, then you can have the Levemir, then the number will fall, then you can't have the Levemir...

 

If the meds are working they should be left in place (IMHO).

 

Jojeti - when I was in the hospital in DKA, the nurses told me I should never let myself go below 90 and I was terrified when I did the first week out. The one good thing I got from my former Endo was that 70's rock! If the occasion arises I will definitely fight with any medico who tells me that living within "normal" range is too low.

 

Jen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jen -- this is not anything anyone said ... just my irrational fear after 14 mos without insulin, that it will be taken away! :)

 

I am perhaps a bit nuts, after this medical experience (well, okay, and before it).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So...I am on Lantus, does that mean I should not go for 80's-90's? I think if someone wants tight control, regardless if they are on insulin, they should be able to do it. It just means more closely watching numbers so you don't get too low.

 

Yes. It can be done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So if you're not on insulin, why do they tell you that your numbers should be higher than non-diabetics?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Jen -- this is not anything anyone said ... just my irrational fear after 14 mos without insulin, that it will be taken away! :)

 

I am perhaps a bit nuts, after this medical experience (well, okay, and before it).

 

LOL...I think you and I are a lot a like! I too am fearful that by gaining tight control my insulin will be taken away!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd suggest the risk of hypos with injected insulin is tied to how well your BGs are controlled. Not everyone can manage this safely (for many different reasons) but if you can achieve stable BG control, I don't see why aiming for lower/normal BGs puts you at any greater risk of hypos than someone with widely swinging BGs who is aiming for an higher average.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It makes sense to me that we could all be aiming for normal BG levels (same as someone who does not have Diabetes) IF normal BG levels can be safely and reasonably achieved -- without frequent hypos, or spending every waking hour as a slave to Diabetes control.

 

I find it a bizarre concept that some feel those of us with Diabetes have a different BG scale than those without Diabetes.

 

We are treated to a stricter standard than the general population when it comes to Blood Pressure (BP) or cholesterol/lipid levels, yet are allowed (even expected) to sail along with higher than normal BGs... which is especially crazy when you consider that higher BG levels can contribute to higher BP and deranged lipid levels.

 

Again, not all of us can achieve normal BG levels all the time but I prefer to have that as the place I ideally aim for, rather than an arbitrarily high level.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'd suggest the risk of hypos with injected insulin is tied to how well your BGs are controlled. Not everyone can manage this safely (for many different reasons) but if you can achieve stable BG control, I don't see why aiming for lower/normal BGs puts you at any greater risk of hypos than someone with widely swinging BGs who is aiming for an higher average.

 

Medical people must not give much credit to diabetics in general. It seems they just assume that diabetics are not able to tightly and safely control their BGL and base all their treatments on these assumptions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi, im a 16 yr old t1 from England,

 

my doctor says the target range is 4-7mmol/l, which equates to 72-126 mg/dl (pre-meal) i think your doctors must not respect your judgement enough to allow you to aim for normal bgl values.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Medical people must not give much credit to diabetics in general. It seems they just assume that diabetics are not able to tightly and safely control their BGL and base all their treatments on these assumptions.

 

Before home-use glucose monitors made MDI practicable, hypos were much more of a threat. Using fixed doses of insulin and requiring people to "cover their insulin", instead of bolusing to cover their carbs, made it much more difficult to control matters. Application of Dr. Bernstein's low-carb approach, based on the Laws of Small Numbers, also helps avoid hypos (by reducing the effects of the myriad variables that affect insulin dosing, absorption, etc., and of miscalculations)--but with his full-on Type 1s, even Dr. Bernstein has them shoot for 90, instead of 83.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe that if it is at all possible, we should aim for the numbers normal people get. I realize that isn't possible for all T2's, but for some, it is.

 

I understand a physician's reluctance when a patient is on insulin, however. The risk of hypos is real and dangerous. That being said, it is possible to maintain tight control and "normal" numbers even when on insulin, but it does require a very active approach.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
hi, im a 16 yr old t1 from England,

 

my doctor says the target range is 4-7mmol/l, which equates to 72-126 mg/dl (pre-meal) i think your doctors must not respect your judgement enough to allow you to aim for normal bgl values.

 

I don't agree, my doctor trusts me and has never said that to me but I think in general, most medical people base their treatments on assumptions rather than looking at the individual. They are doing what they are told to do for this disease.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is also unfortunately the legal side of things where a Doctor may feel protected by advising to shoot for higher BGs -- these may lead to long term complications at some time in the future when they cannot be easily tied to the Doctor's advice, while lower BGs may be seen to cause acute, short-term risk through hypos :(

 

I choose to aim for what I am convinced is the best for me... not for my Doctor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think most doctors don't really KNOW their patients. Some of you may have been seeing your doctor for years (decades? :D ) but consider the average patient. Doctor sees them a few times a year for 30 minutes at a time.

 

Given that, it is not surprising to me that Doctors don't "trust" their patients to be careful enough with their BG levels to recommend the 80s. It is much safer to recommend slightly higher levels.

 

If the average patient is anything like my parents and grandparents, I'm afraid I agree. We at DF are in the tiny, tiny minority of people who geniunely strive to normalize our BG levels. I think the vast majority of diabetics are much more lax and shoot for "close enough" if they even try for that. In those cases, someone in the 80s is "close enough" to a potential hypo to worry docs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I understand what you are saying, I don't think it is really good enough to pander to the lowest common denominator... in my experience if you approach people with low expectations you are unlikely to be disappointed :T but if you challenge expectations you may be surprised to find out how many people will rise to that challenge.

 

I agree that the folks here on DF are in the minority but what makes us different..? Are we somehow especially motivated, or is it perhaps that we have simply become aware that there are different approaches than the standard (low standard) one trotted out by too many heath care providers? I suspect it is some from column A but also some from column B.

 

---

 

If you went to a lawyer to represent you in court and she/he did a poor job because she/he didn't really know you... would that be acceptable to you? It is one thing to recognise that many Doctors may be rushed/overworked etc... and as such end up providing a low standard of care, but it is quite another thing to accept it as normal and not seek to improve the situation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So if you're not on insulin, why do they tell you that your numbers should be higher than non-diabetics?

 

Are you on a BG lowering med? Same principal applies.

If you are just on Metformin then you will probably have high numbers anyway. Of course you can cut the carbs and maby keep your numbers in a safe range....:D If you eat a lot of carbs your numbers will rise. If you don't eat your numbers will rise. Are you confused yet????

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
While I understand what you are saying, I don't think it is really good enough to pander to the lowest common denominator... in my experience if you approach people with low expectations you are unlikely to be disappointed :T but if you challenge expectations you may be surprised to find out how many people will rise to that challenge.

 

I agree that the folks here on DF are in the minority but what makes us different..? Are we somehow especially motivated, or is it perhaps that we have simply become aware that there are different approaches than the standard (low standard) one trotted out by too many heath care providers? I suspect it is some from column A but also some from column B.

 

---

 

If you went to a lawyer to represent you in court and she/he did a poor job because she/he didn't really know you... would that be acceptable to you? It is one thing to recognise that many Doctors may be rushed/overworked etc... and as such end up providing a low standard of care, but it is quite another thing to accept it as normal and not seek to improve the situation.

 

Fgummett,

If I had left my diabetes to be controled by a Doctor I would have been dead 20 years ago. I have only had four Doctors in my 40 years. One Endo(I fired him). Three GP's including the one I have now. Our first meeting goes like this. Doc, I don't need you to take care of my diabeties. I can do that. I need you to provide my insulin, and do the necessary blood work, and God forbid, if I screw up get me out of it. He will advise me if he thinks I am doing something I should not be doing, but we have a good working relationship. I tell them up front I will not take BG lowering oral medication. I will take metformin , and do. The best way for a Doctor to lose me as a patient is screw with the control of MY DIABETES.:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you on a BG lowering med? Same principal applies.

If you are just on Metformin then you will probably have high numbers anyway. Of course you can cut the carbs and maby keep your numbers in a safe range.... If you eat a lot of carbs your numbers will rise. If you don't eat your numbers will rise. Are you confused yet????

 

Sorry, Don.... new to DF so I don't know how to do the quote thing yet. :confused:

 

Yes to all of the above... I was just diagnosed at the beginning of April. Dr put me on 500 mg met 1x per day. I do have higher numbers than most here and really watch my carbs. If I have more than 10-15 carbs at a sitting, I spike to over 200. Morning numbers are in the 110-120 range if I'm careful. I'm still working on it.

 

Morning numbers are within the range the dr wants me to be, but should I be trying for lower? Why settle? Why not try to get the best I can. I may be able to reach the "normal" goal, I may not. But I can try. If hypos are honestly the reason, I can accept that and not try to be at normal bg levels. But are all D's at the same risk for hypos?

 

Yes..... I still get confused. Also need to update my profile with meds and other info. I'll do that soon.

 

Jill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Are you on a BG lowering med? Same principal applies.

If you are just on Metformin then you will probably have high numbers anyway. Of course you can cut the carbs and maby keep your numbers in a safe range.... If you eat a lot of carbs your numbers will rise. If you don't eat your numbers will rise. Are you confused yet????

 

Sorry, Don.... new to DF so I don't know how to do the quote thing yet. :confused:

 

Yes to all of the above... I was just diagnosed at the beginning of April. Dr put me on 500 mg met 1x per day. I do have higher numbers than most here and really watch my carbs. If I have more than 10-15 carbs at a sitting, I spike to over 200. Morning numbers are in the 110-120 range if I'm careful. I'm still working on it.

 

Morning numbers are within the range the dr wants me to be, but should I be trying for lower? Why settle? Why not try to get the best I can. I may be able to reach the "normal" goal, I may not. But I can try. If hypos are honestly the reason, I can accept that and not try to be at normal bg levels. But are all D's at the same risk for hypos?

 

Yes..... I still get confused. Also need to update my profile with meds and other info. I'll do that soon.

 

Jill

 

Just having a bit of fun with you... Just push the Quote box on the right side of the screen...and you are there...I don't think you can ever have the control of a non-diabetic...but you can certainly stay in the high 5's with your A1C's ...I try to stay between 6.1 and 6.4 and have done so for the most part. I have had one 7 in the 40 years I have had this D..Hypos happen you just need to be prepared to take care of them....:fight: on.......:) There were quite a number of years when A1C's didnt exist....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just having a bit of fun with you... Just push the Quote box on the right side of the screen...and you are there...I don't think you can ever have the control of a non-diabetic...but you can certainly stay in the high 5's with your A1C's ...I try to stay between 6.1 and 6.4 and have done so for the most part. I have had one 7 in the 40 years I have had this D..Hypos happen you just need to be prepared to take care of them....:fight: on.......:) There were quite a number of years when A1C's didnt exist....

 

Got the quote thing now.... thanks.....

 

I guess I'm still coming to terms that I have D. Want to have the normal numbers, but just can't. A1C started at 7.5. I go back for my second appt mid-July and really want to see an improvement. Great job on only having one 7 in 40 years! That's fantastic.

 

Jill

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites